NewsRutgers · Governor · Decision · students · Bovino · New Jersey · News

New Jersey’s Governor Called a Rutgers Club’s Invite to Trump’s Ex-Border Chief “the Wrong Decision” — Then He Fired Back in One Line

A petition with 1,600 signatures warned of a “hostile environment.” The club said it believed in “the open market of ideas.” And students dug up one decision from Rutgers’ own past that complicates its free-speech defense.

MV
Marta Visser

16 November 2026 · 5 min read

Former Border Patrol commander Gregory Bovino in Minneapolis, January 2026. File photo. Photo: Chad Davis / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0)

The governor of New Jersey did not try to cancel the speech. She did something more pointed: she told a club of college students, in public and in writing, that they had made “the wrong decision.”

The students were the Rutgers Republicans. The speaker they had booked for Monday night was Gregory Bovino, the former U.S. Border Patrol commander who became the face of President Donald Trump’s toughest immigration crackdowns. The venue was Trayes Hall, inside the Douglass Student Center in New Brunswick, from 6 to 8 p.m.

By Monday, a $730 campus talk had turned into a statewide fight over free speech, immigration and two deaths in Minneapolis. Bovino answered the governor himself. And the money behind the night, and a decision Rutgers made months earlier, gave both sides fresh ammunition.

“Giving Him a Platform Is the Wrong Decision”

Gov. Mikie Sherrill did not mince words. In a post shared across her social media accounts on Monday, the Democrat said she was “deeply disappointed” in the club’s choice.

“Giving him a platform is the wrong decision,” she wrote. “People can agree that border security is important and the need for immigration reform is urgent. They can also reject the cruel policies of officials like Greg Bovino that cost people their lives.”

She stopped short of trying to block the event. Instead, she promised that if the club went ahead, the state would work with Rutgers “to protect the safety of everyone and the rights enshrined in our Constitution.” Then she handed the audience a list of questions. She urged them to ask Bovino “why he chose cruelty over humanity and put Americans’ lives at risk in their own communities,” and what he made of “Americans’ overwhelming rejection of his policies in the midterms.” She closed with a jab at what she called “militias that pledge loyalty to the president instead of the Constitution.”

One Line Back

Bovino did not let it sit. He replied on X, according to Fox News, with a single sentence: “Spoken like a true lib who puts illegals aliens before her own citizens.”

That bluntness is why the invitation was never going to be quiet. As Border Patrol’s commander-at-large, he wore tactical gear during raids in Los Angeles and Chicago, NJ101.5 reported, and oversaw Operation Midway Blitz in Chicago, where the family of Silverio Villegas González, who was killed by ICE officers, is now suing the federal government, according to the Philadelphia Inquirer.

Then came Minneapolis, which NJ101.5 called “the turning point.” More than 2,000 federal officers were sent into the city, where masked agents spilling from convoys of unmarked vehicles became a common sight and tens of thousands of protesters took to the streets. Two U.S. citizens, Renee Good and Alex Pretti, both 37, were killed during confrontations with federal agents. Bovino was removed from command in January, the Inquirer reported, and he left the Border Patrol in March.

Patch reported that he launched a whiskey brand last month with the tagline “Deport them all,” and Fox News says he has reportedly explored a 2028 presidential run.

The Post That Followed Him to New Jersey

For many opponents, the anger was also local. In May, during protests at the Delaney Hall immigration detention center in Newark, Bovino posted a message of encouragement to ICE agents there.

“ICE Agents at Delaney, hang in there. You have the world watching and supporting your efforts to hold the line. Every one of us wants to be shoulder to shoulder with you,” he wrote, according to NJ101.5, alongside a photo that some viewers said resembled a Nazi salute. Online critics had already mocked his olive, double-breasted coat as “Nazi cosplay,” NJ.com reported.

More than 1,600 people signed a petition from the Climate Revolution Action Network asking Rutgers to cancel the talk. Bovino’s presence, it warned, “risks creating an intimidating and hostile environment for Rutgers students,” especially for the school’s “large immigrant and international student population as well as undocumented students and their families.”

Brea Yumiguano, a Rutgers senior and the group’s campus manager, put it more bluntly to NJ.com. “We don’t stand for fascists,” she said. “We don’t stand for Nazis within our town.” Organizers also planned an anti-ICE rally outside the Douglass Student Center at 5 p.m., an hour before he was due to speak.

“We Believe in the Open Market of Ideas”

“I can see why he’s very inflammatory,” Joseph told NJ.com. “I’m willing to take the risk on that. We are the Rutgers Republicans. We believe in the open market of ideas.” He said students were “only hearing about one perspective on immigration, which is a left-wing one,” and invited opponents to come and join the discussion.

Bovino was not even his first choice. The club first asked James Fishback, who ran unsuccessfully for the Republican nomination for governor of Florida, but the timing did not work. Bovino accepted about three weeks ago.

What hardened many opponents was something Joseph said about the Minneapolis deaths. “The deaths are tragic, but at the same time though, they were interrupting with what border enforcement were doing,” he told NJ.com. “If you do that, don’t expect that there isn’t going to be any consequences.”

The Detail That Complicates Everything

Bovino’s fee, about $730, was paid from a fund the university provides to student organizations, according to Joseph, as reported by NJ101.5 and NJ.com. In other words, the speaker the governor condemned was booked with money set aside for student clubs.

Rutgers defended the club anyway. “As a public university, Rutgers is committed to protecting freedom of expression, even when views expressed may be controversial or generate disagreement,” spokeswoman Megan Florance said. Recognized student groups may invite speakers, she added, and the university has no say in who they choose. An area was designated for “those who wish to express opposing views.”

But students opposed to the event had a ready reply. At a student assembly meeting last Thursday, senior Jakob Pender pointed out that Rutgers had rescinded a convocation speech by biotech CEO and alumnus Rami Elghandour over his past social media posts, something he said happened “just months ago,” The Daily Targum reported. “If inflammatory social media posts are enough for Rutgers to cancel a speaker,” Pender said, “how about inflammatory actions?”

Sherrill’s own record drew fire too. The Inquirer noted that some progressives had blasted the governor for sending state police, in riot gear and on horseback, to break up protests outside the same Delaney Hall center in Newark.

So a governor called the invitation wrong but promised to protect it. Students demanded a cancellation the university said it couldn’t give. And the man at the center of it all answered a sitting governor in one line, then walked into a hall booked with $730 of campus club money.

Should a public university give a platform to a speaker like Greg Bovino, or was the governor right to call it the wrong decision? What are your thoughts?

Marta Visser

Consumer editor

Marta has covered retail pricing and consumer rights for nine years and runs our basket-tracking tests.

One email a week. Every deal, checked.

No spam, no filler. Just the prices, recalls and stories that affect your week.

Keep reading