NewsFiona · Hippo · On Nov · Pounds · Cincinnati · Born · News · Lifestyle

Fiona the Hippo Survived Being Born at 29 Pounds — So How Did a Knit Hat Kill Her at 9?

The Cincinnati Zoo tried a borrowed 9-foot scope, a horse-farm vibration plate and even a sniff of coffee. Experts now explain why surgery was never really an option — and why fans are leaving a watermelon at the gates.

MV
Marta Visser

20 November 2026 · 5 min read

Fiona the hippo swimming beside her mother, Bibi, at the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden in May 2018. Fiona died on Nov. 19, 2026, at age 9. File photo. Photo: DarthBotto / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 4.0), cropped and color-adjusted.

Olivia Earls went to Kroger to buy flowers. She walked out with a watermelon.

It now sits among the candles, cards and bouquets piling up outside the Cincinnati Zoo & Botanical Garden — an odd, perfect offering for a hippo who loved the fruit. “What do you do for a family when they lose somebody? You know, you bring them a casserole,” Earls told WCPO. “And I know Fiona loved watermelon... It just seemed like the right thing to do.”

Fiona, the hippo who was never supposed to survive her own birth, died on Thursday, Nov. 19. She was nine years old. The zoo says it all traces back to one small, ordinary object: a knit hat.

Fans everywhere are now asking: how does a soft winter hat bring down an animal that weighs more than 2,500 pounds — one that had already beaten impossible odds once?

“She Fought Until She Couldn’t Anymore”

The zoo broke the news at roughly 4 p.m. Thursday, according to the Cincinnati Enquirer. “It is with extreme sadness that we share with you the devastating news that Fiona did not make it after multiple attempts from our amazing vets and keeper team to help her through what ended up being a medical emergency,” it wrote on social media.

Zoo director Dave Jenike sounded stunned. “We are in shock at the moment,” he said in the zoo’s statement. “We did not expect this outcome. She fought until she couldn’t anymore.”

On Thursday, the team performed “necessary supportive care” in a last attempt to save her. She did not recover. “They did everything possible, but her body couldn’t fight anymore,” Jenike said.

“Fiona was such a gift,” said former zoo director Thane Maynard. “I have never known an animal so beloved in all my life. From the day she was born, she was like lightning in a bottle.”

It began on Nov. 8 with pure bad luck. A child visiting Hippo Cove tossed a knit hat into the air. A ceiling fan caught it and flung it through a 1-foot gap above the 12-foot-tall viewing window, straight into Fiona’s habitat, according to the Enquirer and the Associated Press. She swallowed part of it.

“We probably couldn’t make [it] happen again if we tried,” zoo spokesperson Michelle Curley told reporters, the BBC reported.

Fiona seemed fine at first. Days later, her appetite faded. On Nov. 16 the zoo pulled her from Hippo Cove “indefinitely” and put her under round-the-clock watch.

What followed was a medical fight that played out in public. Keepers tried enemas, anti-nausea medicine, fluids and her favorite foods. An ultrasound showed what staff described as “some bunching of intestines,” a hint the hat might be moving. On Nov. 17 the Columbus Zoo lent a 9-foot scope for a colonoscopy, but the team still could not reach the hat.

On Nov. 18 a local horse farm sent over a vibration plate, hoping the shaking would nudge the hat along. That evening came a moment fans clung to. “Her care team even offered her a sniff of coffee, a scent she always has really liked, and they were happy to see her respond,” the zoo posted, according to WIRED.

Less than 24 hours later, she was gone.

Why a Hat Can Kill a Hippo

Surgery, the obvious answer to anyone whose dog has swallowed a sock, was ruled out. A zookeeper said it was not an option for a full-grown hippo and that “our best chance for success with Fiona would be if she could pass this on her own,” the BBC reported.

Rebecca Lewison, co-chair of the IUCN’s Hippo Specialist Group, told WIRED that hippos have “unpredictable and irregular responses to sedation and anesthesia.” “It is very risky for [hippos], and they can die from the standard medication used on other large animals, like elephants and rhinos, for reasons we don’t well understand,” she said.

Then there is the plumbing. Jan Hawkins, head of clinical sciences at North Carolina State University’s vet school, said a hippo’s intestinal tract is likely more than 100 feet long, with over 70 feet of small intestine alone. If the hat was going to pass, she said, it probably would have done so within about five days.

When something gets stuck, Hawkins explained, swelling can cut off blood flow and kill the surrounding tissue, which may leak and send toxins into the bloodstream. The gut can also twist around a heavy object. Either way, organs can start to fail. Only a post-mortem exam will confirm what happened to Fiona, and the zoo has not released one.

The Hippo Who Wasn’t Supposed to Live

What makes the loss hit so hard is how it began. Fiona was born six weeks early on Jan. 24, 2017, weighing just 29 pounds, 25 pounds lighter than the smallest Nile hippo ever recorded, according to the Enquirer. The zoo’s staff became the first to hand-raise a Nile hippo.

About a month in, she was teething, dehydrated and dying. Her IV lines would not stay in, and her skin had the texture of a cantaloupe. Nurses from Cincinnati Children’s came over with ultrasound equipment meant for human babies and found her veins. By late February she was gaining weight and wiggling her ears again.

Hippos can live up to 50 years in human care. Fiona was two months short of turning 10.

Mayor Aftab Pureval called her “a symbol of perseverance and joy,” writing on X: “Our city is heartbroken, but we couldn’t be more grateful that she was part of our lives and our community as a whole.”

Not every reaction was a eulogy. PETA’s Debbie Metzler said that while this “was not an intentional incident,” Fiona’s death is “a tragic reminder that everyone should behave carefully and respectfully around animals.” PETA said it expects the zoo to review its protocols. Zoo designers face a real trade-off, Aurora University lecturer Paul Eberhart told WKRC before her death: “the more barriers you throw up” between guests and animals, “the weaker that connection is going to be.”

Lights On at the Zoo

Fiona leaves behind her mother, Bibi, and her younger brother, Fritz. Her father, Henry, died before her. The zoo has asked for space for the people who cared for her.

Outside the gates, the memorial keeps growing. Six-year-old Bristol Makin, who has visited Fiona since she was a baby, read her goodbye aloud to WLWT: “I’ll miss Fiona. I love her. Love, Bristol.” Debbie Manning, who leaned on Fiona’s story through cancer, said: “I would think back on Fiona, how she fought and fought and won. And that’s what she was to everybody, an inspiration.”

Jeremiah Garvey and his daughter, Kinsley, heard the news by phone just minutes before walking into the zoo’s Festival of Lights. “So we sat outside and cried for a minute,” he told WCPO, “and then we came in and enjoyed the lights.”

Kinsley left holding a stuffed Fiona.

Marta Visser

Consumer editor

Marta has covered retail pricing and consumer rights for nine years and runs our basket-tracking tests.

One email a week. Every deal, checked.

No spam, no filler. Just the prices, recalls and stories that affect your week.

Keep reading