Mamdani Vowed to Close Rikers Island “Once and for All” — Then Critics Did the Math on the New Jails
New York’s mayor has a six-year plan to empty America’s most notorious jail complex. It hinges on one number — and his critics say that number doesn’t add up.
20 November 2026 · 5 min read

On Friday morning, New York City’s official mayoral account posted seven words and a video: “We’re closing Rikers once and for all.”
By Friday night it had been seen more than 13 million times. Within hours, a former police commissioner was calling the plan “insanity,” the correction officers’ union was calling it unrealistic, and advocates who have marched for years to shut the island down were calling it the moment they had been waiting for.
The plan Mayor Zohran Mamdani released on Nov. 20 is the city’s first full roadmap for closing Rikers Island, the 1930s-era jail complex in the East River that has become a national symbol of violence and dysfunction. But buried in its pages is a simple piece of arithmetic that now sits at the center of the fight. The new jail system meant to replace it will hold about 4,500 people. Rikers holds about 6,600 today.
Seven Words and a Six-Year Clock
Under the plan, the new borough jails open one by one: Brooklyn in 2029, the Bronx and Queens in 2031, and Manhattan in 2032. Rikers would be fully emptied by the end of 2032 — more than five years after the Aug. 31, 2027 deadline written into a 2019 city law. The mayor can’t move that date on his own. The City Council has to pass a new law.
“It is time to finally close Rikers Island,” Mamdani said in a statement. “We have a legal and moral obligation to close Rikers.” The new timeline, he said, was “made necessary by the prior administrations delays.”
The idea dates back to Mayor Ed Koch in the late 1970s. It gained real force after Kalief Browder, a Bronx teenager accused of stealing a backpack, spent three years on Rikers, much of it in solitary confinement, before his case was dismissed. He died by suicide two years later. In 2019 the Council voted to close the island. Since then, construction has lagged, costs have nearly doubled, the jail population has climbed back up, and a federal judge has handed broad control of the jails to an outside remediation manager.
At least nine people have died in Department of Correction custody this year, according to Gothamist. The plan itself admits that some 2,450 doors across the complex still need to be replaced.
The Number Critics Can’t Get Past
To fit inside the new buildings, the city has to shrink its jail population to no more than 5,500 by 2029 and 4,100 by the end of 2032 — a cut of nearly 40%.
That is where the backlash landed hardest. “Does any sane, rational person believe that in a city of over 8 million people there are only 3,500 criminals who need to be incarcerated?” former NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton wrote on X, calling City Hall’s move “insanity.”
The Correction Officers’ Benevolent Association, which represents the people who work inside the jails, said the population wind-down was unrealistic and called for state-of-the-art facilities on Rikers itself. The administration “cannot build a safer NYC by simply reducing jail capacity,” union president Benny Boscio wrote, according to Gothamist.
Staten Island Republican Councilman Frank Morano said he will vote against the extension. “We have an entire island that the City already owns, geographically separated from residential neighborhoods, where we could build modern correctional facilities,” he said, as reported by Los Angeles magazine. “I have never understood how changing the ZIP code of a jail is supposed to fix the way it’s run.” He added: “The number of jail beds we build should be determined by our public safety needs. Our public safety decisions should not be determined by the number of jail beds politicians have decided to build.”
Four of the city’s district attorneys welcomed the effort in a joint statement while warning that “we have a long way to go and many obstacles to overcome.” And the plan has no stated backup if the population is still too big when the last jail opens. The report says its own estimates are “not meant to be a forecast.”
Why Supporters Say the Math Works
The administration’s answer is that Rikers is crowded not because of crime, but because of time.
About 85% of the people in city jails have not been convicted — they are waiting for trial. The median felony case in New York City takes 431 days from arrest to final outcome, roughly four months longer than in the rest of the state. Since 2017, the number of people sent to Rikers before trial has fallen 56%, yet the jail population has dropped only 22%, because each stay keeps getting longer.
City officials estimate that clearing court delays alone could cut the daily population by about 800 people, with roughly 1,700 more coming from diversion programs, targeted releases and efforts to stop people from cycling back in. Behind it sits $146 million next fiscal year and about $290 million through 2030 for mental health care, drug treatment, job training, supervised release, reentry housing and $16 million for crime victims. Electronic monitoring would double to 800 slots.
“We do not want any New Yorker to spend a day longer in detention than necessary,” Mamdani said.
It has happened before: during the COVID-19 pandemic, the jail population fell below 4,000 for the first time since the 1940s. “We can finally remove this moral stain from our city, once and for all,” said Darren Mack, co-director of Freedom Agenda and a former Rikers detainee. Zachary Katznelson of the Independent Rikers Commission called the plan a “return to common sense” that would make New Yorkers safer.
Attacked From Both Sides
The pressure doesn’t only come from the right. The New York Civil Liberties Union criticized the five-year delay itself: “Every day it remains open, the lives and well-being of the New Yorkers forced to be there are at risk.” In Chinatown, where the Manhattan jail will rise last, one resident told ABC7 that six years of round-the-clock construction next to a senior center was “an injustice.”
And Elizabeth Glazer, who helped write the original closure plan under Mayor Bill de Blasio, warned that without deep reform of the Department of Correction, the city “risks merely exporting the violence of Rikers into new ZIP codes.”
The man now running that department has seen it from the inside. Stanley Richards, the city’s first formerly incarcerated correction commissioner, was held on Rikers more than four decades ago. “I remember crossing that bridge to Rikers Island,” he said, as reported by ABC7.
What Happens Next
Nothing changes on the island tomorrow. The City Council still has to write and pass the law that sets 2032 as the new deadline, and Morano has already promised to vote no. The administration has promised quarterly progress reports.
Until then, the fight comes down to a single question the plan can’t settle by itself: is Rikers full because the city needs that many cells — or because the system is too slow to let people go home?
Should New York close Rikers, even if it means jailing fewer people — or fix the island it already has? What are your thoughts?
Marta Visser
Consumer editor
Marta has covered retail pricing and consumer rights for nine years and runs our basket-tracking tests.
One email a week. Every deal, checked.
No spam, no filler. Just the prices, recalls and stories that affect your week.





