Newsmoney · Press Herald · Years · Town · Police · Safe · News

Someone Left $55,737 in a Safe in the Woods Behind a Fire Station — Four Years Later, a Maine Town Decided Who Gets It

Police traced the cash to a bank, checked two states and waited four years for an owner who never came. The chief has a theory about why it was there — and the town now has a plan for every dollar.

MV
Marta Visser

18 November 2026 · 5 min read

A pile of U.S. $20, $50 and $100 bills. File photo, not the Falmouth cash. Photo: Tracy O / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY-SA 2.0)

The trail behind Falmouth’s Central Fire Station is barely a trail at all — a short cut through the woods that links the firehouse to the town’s baseball fields. In August 2022, a resident walking it noticed something that did not belong among the trees: a safe, lying on the ground.

They pointed it out to the Falmouth Police Department, and the safe was turned over to officers. When police cut it open, they found a pile of cash that would sit in the department’s evidence room for the next four years.

The total came to $55,737. Police checked with agencies in two states, traced the bills to a bank and put the word out in the newspapers. Not one person ever came forward to say it was theirs. Now the small Maine town just north of Portland has decided where every dollar goes — and the answer has nothing to do with whoever left it there.

“I’ve Never Experienced Anything Like That”

Falmouth Police Chief John Kilbride has spent three decades in law enforcement. Nothing in that time prepared him for this.

“Cash of this magnitude is very unusual,” Kilbride told the Portland Press Herald. “I’ve never experienced anything like that in my 30 years.”

His department did what the law asks of anyone holding a stranger’s property. Officers contacted police agencies across Maine and New Hampshire, asking whether anyone had reported a large sum of money stolen from a person or a bank. The department also published newspaper notices saying it had found money — without saying how much.

Investigators also traced the cash itself to a bank in New Hampshire, police told WGME. The bank had an answer of its own: the money was not stolen.

So it was not loot from a robbery. It was not a bank’s missing deposit. And yet $55,737 had ended up in a box in the woods behind a fire station, and whoever put it there never came back.

There was one detail that told the chief more than the notices ever did. The bills were dry.

To Kilbride, that meant the safe had not been sitting outside for long when it was spotted. Put together with the fact that nobody claimed a fortune in cash, it pointed him toward one theory. His best guess, he told the Press Herald, was that the safe had been placed in the woods for a drug-related exchange.

“We’re surmising it was there for pickup and something else was going to get dropped off,” he told WGME. “But we don’t know.”

That is as close as anyone has come to an explanation. Officers have never been able to find out who the money belonged to, and how it found its way to the woods remains a mystery.

Why Police Waited Four Years

Under Maine law, the cash could have been dealt with much sooner. After six months with no leads, the safe and its contents were officially classified as abandoned property — joining the department’s collection of unclaimed bikes, kayaks, wallets and jewelry.

State statute says that once police have made a sufficient effort to find an owner and at least six months have passed, the chief can decide what happens next: donate the property to a nonprofit, throw it away or sell it to the highest bidder.

Kilbride chose to wait. His reasoning was quietly human. If the money had been taken from the home of an older person, he told the Press Herald, it might take them, or their family, far longer to notice it was gone. He wanted to leave the door open for someone like that.

Nobody walked through it. After four years, the chief decided it was time for the money to leave the evidence room. Unclaimed items usually end up at the Falmouth Lions Club’s auction or a secondhand store. This time he had the $55,737 deposited into the town’s account, to be used for charitable purposes, as state law requires.

“This is the people’s money,” Kilbride said.

A Winter Nobody Can Afford

Town Manager Nathan Poore did not need long to decide what the people needed.

The timing could hardly be sharper. Roughly half of Maine households rely on heating oil, and the state burns more residential heating oil per person than any other, according to American Community Survey data cited by the paper. At the end of October, the Maine Department of Energy Resources said prices had hit a record high — up 82% from a year earlier — meaning Mainers would pay about $750 more than last fall to fill a standard 275-gallon tank. The department put the price at $6.05 a gallon at its peak, The Independent reported, before it eased slightly to $5.84 by Nov. 9.

The Falmouth Town Council voted to put the money into a Low Income Home Energy Assistance fund. Residents who apply and are approved for the statewide Home Energy Assistance Program, known as HEAP, will be eligible for the town’s help too, Poore said. The money can go toward heating fuel, an electricity bill, or rent when the rent includes utilities.

In past years, about 50 people have applied when the town ran heating help. Poore said he will probably start by granting $500 per applicant, with whatever is left handed out in more rounds. The money is expected to be available starting in January.

Town Council Chair Bryce Hach called the decision a no-brainer.

“It was certainly an intriguing way of getting funds,” Hach told WGME. “This was not taxpayer money. This was not something that was a product of any thoughtful policy. This was literally a find in the woods.”

“An incredible find has turned into an enormous amount of serendipity,” he added, “given the timing we are in right now, looking at the winter and where fuel costs are.”

The Money That Fell in Their Lap

Poore has worked for Falmouth for 20 years. The town has run short-term heating programs a handful of times over the past two decades — during the Great Recession, during the pandemic — and each time about $50,000 went into the pot. Never before has it come from a safe in the woods.

“I’ve never had the experience where we stumbled upon some found money and had to spend on charitable purposes,” he said. “I don’t ever recall anything like this.”

Somewhere, someone may still know exactly how $55,737 came to be lying behind a fire station on a summer day in 2022. They never asked for it back. This winter, it will help pay for heating fuel and electric bills in Falmouth homes.

“This was a true gift for our community,” Hach said, “and one that literally fell in our lap.”

Marta Visser

Consumer editor

Marta has covered retail pricing and consumer rights for nine years and runs our basket-tracking tests.

One email a week. Every deal, checked.

No spam, no filler. Just the prices, recalls and stories that affect your week.

Keep reading