A Pregnant U.S. Citizen Was Pepper-Sprayed and Pinned Face-Down by ICE Outside a California Jail — Now ICE Says She’s the One Who Broke the Law
Her husband’s video catches him shouting “She’s pregnant with child!” seconds before agents put her on the pavement. She was released without a single charge. Then the agency described her conduct in words that have only poured fuel on the fight.
17 November 2026 · 6 min read

The video is shaky, and the sound keeps cutting out. A minivan sits in the parking lot outside the Stanislaus County jail in Modesto, California. Federal agents in law enforcement vests move around it, at least two of them with masks over their faces. A young woman in a blue sweatshirt holds up her phone, live-streaming.
Then the man behind the camera shouts the line now travelling far beyond California’s Central Valley.
“She’s pregnant with child!”
Seconds later, two agents take her to the pavement and handcuff her with her stomach pressed against the ground.
The woman is Lizbeth Vargas Andrade, 23, a U.S. citizen from nearby Ceres who is 12 weeks pregnant. She was held for hours and released Sunday night without a single charge, her attorney says. On Tuesday, Immigration and Customs Enforcement gave its account. It did not apologize. It said she was the one breaking the law.
A Ride, Five Cars and a Phone in the Air
It started, by the family’s account, with an offer of a ride.
Vargas Andrade told KCRA that a friend had spotted a man walking out of the jail on Sunday afternoon and offered to drive him. “She was driving off down the street, and that’s when they all pulled her over. There were like five ICE cars,” she said. ABC News reported that the driver was her sister-in-law, Monica Alvarado, who says officers forced their way into her vehicle, claiming she was transporting strangers.
Vargas Andrade wasn’t there by chance. She belongs to what she calls a walkie-talkie community of more than 600 people, from Stockton to Modesto, who watch for “suspicious vehicles” that might signal ICE activity, the Modesto Bee reported. When agents were spotted near the jail, protesters gathered.
She says she was careful. She held one arm up to film and kept the other hand raised to show she was no threat. “Because I understand that if you have your hand in your pocket, they can assume things,” she told reporters.
The video, recorded by her husband, Adolfo Talavera Alvarado, also shows something more heated. About a minute in, KCRA reported, she is yelling at one of the agents and following him closely around the vehicle. He appears to turn around to detain her.
“I Couldn’t Breathe”
What happened next is the heart of the dispute.
“He backed up into me. We bumped. ‘She hit me! She hit me!’ We bumped,” Vargas Andrade told CBS News Sacramento. “That’s when everything started. They started holding my hands with my phone in my hand. I was trying to still go around. That’s when another agent maced me and dropped me to the floor.”
The footage shows a second agent pointing what appears to be a pepper-spray canister toward her and her husband, The Guardian reported, though it is hard to tell how long he sprayed or where it landed. Then comes the shout about the baby, and the takedown.
“I told the ICE agent … ‘I’m pregnant, so don’t put your hands on me,’” she said at a news conference Sunday night. “They right away threw me on the floor … I was burning. I couldn’t breathe. The mace went up my nose.” Another agent, she said, gave her water to wash her face.
Her sister-in-law alleged that one officer made “smart remarks like ‘Everybody’s pregnant all of a sudden,’” the Bee reported.
For her husband, the fear was specific. Vargas Andrade, a mother of two, has suffered two previous miscarriages. “I got scared,” Talavera said. “I was like, what if she has a miscarriage?”
Five Hours, No Charges
She was driven to an ICE field office in Stockton and held for hours. She says she was denied a medical exam and kept from contacting her attorney, Patrick Kolasinski, until her sister called an ambulance to the facility. At the hospital, Vargas Andrade said, “My sugar was super high. My blood pressure was super high.” She is diabetic.
An ultrasound showed the baby was unharmed. She was released around 8 p.m. She was not fingerprinted, Kolasinski said, and no charges have been filed against her.
“ICE took a U.S. citizen and held her five hours without medical care,” Kolasinski said, arguing that ICE “likes to invent” crimes like obstructing an agent. “What I see is too many, too close. It’s clear ICE isn’t trained,” he told CBS News Sacramento. He says it is too early to decide on legal action.
ICE’s Answer: “A Federal Crime”
Federal officials did not answer reporters on Monday. On Tuesday, ICE told KCRA and CBS News Sacramento that the agents were arresting Fabian Santiago Martinez, a Mexican national who the agency says had entered the country illegally, had been charged with multiple DUIs and had agreed to return to Mexico voluntarily.
Then it turned to Vargas Andrade.
“During the arrest, a female individual actively interfered with, obstructed, and attempted to prevent the arrest — a federal crime,” the statement said. “Our ICE officer relied on his training to safely control the situation despite the combative, aggressive, and heinously vulgar conduct of the woman interfering with his lawful duties.”
The agency said she “immediately received medical care” and was taken to San Joaquin General Hospital for evaluation, and that its officers “are trained to use the minimum amount of force necessary to resolve dangerous situations to prioritize the safety of the public and our officers.” Obstructing law enforcement, it added, “is a federal crime and assaulting law enforcement is a felony.”
That is the strongest version of the case for the agents: a lawful arrest of a man the agency says faced multiple DUI charges, a protester who, as KCRA described the footage, followed an agent closely around a vehicle while yelling at him, and an officer who had seconds to decide. For critics, the same seconds tell a different story: a pregnant citizen, a husband shouting a warning, and a takedown onto her stomach anyway, followed by hours in custody and no charges at all.
The Guardian noted that federal officials have repeatedly accused anti-ICE protesters of assaulting agents, but many of those prosecutions in California have fallen apart in federal court.
A Valley on Edge
Local authorities want no part of it. The Stanislaus County Sheriff’s Office said its deputies were not involved and that it “continues to operate within its lawful boundaries, including SB 54,” California’s law limiting local help with immigration enforcement. Modesto police posted a similar message.
Harlen Diven, an attorney who helped the family, said the Central Valley has been “ravaged by ICE for about a month.” The watch network Vargas Andrade belongs to, she said, is simply “neighbors looking out for neighbors.”
Vargas Andrade isn’t backing down. “I was using all my rights to protest and to record and show everybody in the world what was going on,” she told KCRA. “We’re not going to stop helping the community even though this happened,” she said. “We want our immigrants to feel safe here.”
ICE says the law was on its side. Her lawyer says the agency invents crimes. The video is out there for everyone to judge. What are your thoughts?
Marta Visser
Consumer editor
Marta has covered retail pricing and consumer rights for nine years and runs our basket-tracking tests.
One email a week. Every deal, checked.
No spam, no filler. Just the prices, recalls and stories that affect your week.





